Rapid Reviews: Vital signs in CVAs – which arm?
by Alan Batt. Last modified: 07/02/14
This question often arises – in patients with a CVA, which arm should be used for blood pressure and vital sign measurement? Only just today we were asked this very same question again. Below are some readings on this topic, but the issue is lacking in recent robust research and evidence-based recommendations. Our conclusion from reading the literature is to go with the recommendation of using the non-affected arm for measurement of BP and pulse oximetry; we also recommend future robust research be carried out in this area to guide practice.
1. The effect of hemiplegia on blood pressure measurement in the elderly.
2. Blood pressure monitoring in hemiplegic patients.
Letter to the Editor Fulltext (free): http://journals.lww.com/anesthesia-analgesia/Fulltext/1996/02000/Blood_Pressure_Monitoring_in_Hemiplegic_Patients.66.aspx
3. Blood Pressure Measurement in Hemiparetic Patients: Which Arm?
Fulltext (free): http://www.stfm.org/fmhub/fm2008/September/Annemarie540.pdf
4. Effect of Hemiparetic Stroke on Pulse Oximetry Readings on the Affected Side
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Hypoxia is common after stroke, and monitoring by pulse oximetry is suggested in the acute phase. Physical changes on the affected side or intravenous infusions may affect oximeter readings. This study was designed to test whether pulse oximetry recordings are the same on the affected and nonaffected sides in stroke patients.
METHODS: Oxygen saturation (SpO(2)) and heart rate (HR) were assessed simultaneously in the left and right hands in patients with hemiparetic stroke over a 3-hour period with 2 Minolta Pulsox-3i oximeters attached to the index fingers.
RESULTS: Fifteen patients (53% men; 67% left hemiparesis; mean age, 73 years [SD, 7.5 years]) were recruited. HR and SpO(2) (12 measurements per minute) were monitored. The maximum difference between simultaneous left and right arm readings was 2% SpO(2). HR fluctuated more, but no affected/nonaffected side pattern was seen. Means for each patient of HR and SpO(2) for the affected and nonaffected sides were compared by t tests. Mean SpO(2) was 96% (SD, 1%) on both sides. Mean HR was 81 bpm (SD, 11 bpm) on the affected side and 80 bpm (SD, 10 bpm) on the nonaffected side. There was no significant difference between the 2 sides for either parameter (n=15; P=0.86 for SpO(2) and P=0.91 for HR).
CONCLUSIONS: Oximeters can be attached to either the affected or nonaffected side in hemiparetic stroke. Full text (free): http://stroke.ahajournals.org/content/32/8/1808.long
5. Stroke emergency: evidence favours laying the patient on the paretic side.Brainin M, Funk G, Dachenhausen A, Huber G, Matz K, Eckhardt R. Stroke emergency: evidence favours laying the patient on the paretic side. Wien Med Wochenschr. 2004 Dec;154(23-24):568-70. PMID: 15675430.
In the preclinical phase of stroke care there are still many uncertainties. One of them includes the decision on which side to lie an acute stroke victim until professional help arrives and the patient is transported to hospital.
METHODS AND RESULTS:
This controlled study aimed at finding possible advantages of laying the patient on the paretic versus the non-paretic side in the acute phase. In 10 consecutive patients (five right-sided and five left-sided paresis) no differences were noted when comparing vital parameters including peripheral oxygen saturation, mean arterial blood pressure, breathing pattern, or ECG changes.
Patients should preferably be positioned on the paretic side to prevent aspiration, to have the unaffected arm free for movement and to avoid additional hemianopia or visual hemineglect to the paretic side possibly disrupting communication with the helpers.
6. Interarm blood pressure difference in acute hemiplegia.
Blood pressure was measured in 15 patients with acute hemiparesis and flaccidity and found the systolic and diastolic blood pressures to be higher in the paretic arm in 8 of 15 patients and lower in 7 of the 15 patients.
7. Measuring Blood Pressure: Which Arm?
Barnabas N. Panayiotou, MRCP JAMA. 1995;274(17):1343
Letter to the Editor Fulltext (free): http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=389907
What are your thoughts? Any additional evidence for or against the recommendation of using the non-affected arm?
Dewar R, Sykes D, Mulkerrin E, Nicklason F, Thomas D, Seymour R. The effect of hemiplegia on blood pressure measurement in the elderly. Postgrad Med J. 1992 Nov;68(805):888-91. PMID: 1494509.
Uijen AA, Hassink-Franke LJ. Blood pressure measurement in hemiparetic patients: which arm? Fam Med. 2008 Sep;40(8):540. PMID: 18988037.4.
Roffe C, Sills S, Wilde K, Crome P. Effect of hemiparetic stroke on pulse oximetry readings on the affected side. Stroke. 2001 Aug;32(8):1808-10. PMID: 11486109.
Brainin M, Funk G, Dachenhausen A, Huber G, Matz K, Eckhardt R. Stroke emergency: evidence favours laying the patient on the paretic side. Wien Med Wochenschr. 2004 Dec;154(23-24):568-70. PMID: 15675430.
Panayiotou BN, Harper GD, Fotherby MD, Potter JF, Castleden CM. Interarm blood pressure difference in acute hemiplegia. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1993 Apr;41(4):422-3. PMID: 8463530.The following two tabs change content below.Paramedic, educator, researcherAlan is a critical care paramedic, paramedic educator and prehospital researcher, currently working around the world as an educator and researcher. He has previously worked and studied across Europe, North America and the Middle East. He holds a Graduate Certificate in Intensive Care Paramedic Studies, and an MSc in Critical Care. His main interests are in care of the elderly, end-of-life care, patient safety, professionalism (including role and identity), and paramedic education.
Latest posts by Alan Batt (see all)
- Free access: Resuscitation Today Vol 3 Issue 2 - 27/06/16
- Free CPD at the Emergency Services Show - 23/05/16
- Care at the Scene – Research for Ambulance Services - 17/05/16
- Canadian Paramedicine Feb/Mar 2016 – Open Access Issue - 11/04/16
- Eat, sleep and be healthy – a paramedic’s guide to healthier shift work - 10/04/16
Rapid Reviews: Vital signs in CVAs – which arm?
Get weekly email updates!
Cast Your Vote
- Blogs (40)
- Case Studies (8)
- Featured Article (23)
- How-To (47)
- FOAM (8)
- News (117)
- Conference Tweets (31)
- Pharmacology (1)
- Adrenaline (1)
- Research (180)
- Advanced Practice (2)
- Airway Management (6)
- Anaphylaxis (2)
- Cardiac (15)
- Community Paramedic (2)
- Critical Care Paramedic (4)
- Diagnostics (3)
- Dispatch (1)
- ECG (4)
- Education (10)
- EMS Operations (2)
- End-of-Life Care (3)
- Geriatrics (9)
- Guidelines (22)
- HEMS (4)
- Mass Casualty (2)
- Medical Conditions (5)
- Mental Health (7)
- Military & Tactical (2)
- Neonatal (1)
- Neuro (11)
- Obstetrics (1)
- Paediatrics (4)
- Pain Management (4)
- Poster Presentations (5)
- Professionalism (5)
- Remote, Industrial & Austere (6)
- Respiratory (5)
- Resuscitation (27)
- Rural (3)
- Safety (3)
- Sepsis (7)
- Shock (2)
- Simulation (7)
- Sports Medicine (1)
- Trauma (20)
- Reviews (6)
There are no upcoming events at this time.
- Free access: Resuscitation Today Vol 3 Issue 2 (27/06/16)
- Free CPD at the Emergency Services Show (23/05/16)
- Canadian Paramedicine Feb/Mar 2016 – Open Access Issue (11/04/16)
- Free access: Resuscitation Today Volume 3 Issue 1 (01/04/16)
- Introducing the Irish Journal of Paramedicine (22/11/15)
Latest How-To Articles
- Paramedic students…write something! (28/04/16)
- Understanding diagnostic tests 2: likelihood ratios, pre- and post-test probabilities and their use in clinical practice (30/01/15)
- Understanding diagnostic tests 1: sensitivity, specificity and predictive values (11/12/14)
- GRADE guidelines – best practices using the GRADE framework (22/11/14)
- How to get started with EMS research – JEMS (16/05/14)
academic ACS airway management ambulance AMI Australia Canada cardiac cardiac arrest case study clinical management computer conference consensus CPG CPR CPR UL critical care CVA database ECG education elderly emergency EMS evidence based FOAM FPHC geriatric guide guideline guidelines haemorrhage HEMS Ireland journal medication mental health neurology news OHCA online paediatric pain management paramedic prehospital PTSD reference research resuscitation review safety sepsis septic shock simulation social media software spinal STEMI stress stroke Student Paramedic study TBI training Translational Health Sciences trauma Twitter UK USA